« TalkShoe to Pay Podcasters to Host Shows | Main | links for 2006-06-23 »

Thursday, June 22, 2006

Cuban Kills Blog Comments

Dallas Mavericks owner and blogger Mark Cuban has disabled the ability for readers to leave comments. In a post about being called names he finishes by saying:"For the record, Im not turning on comments, they have devolved to the point where they add no value."

Mark's move is quite surprising. He has been open to feedback throughout his entire career, especially after he became a billionaire. In fact, his consistent approachability is nothing short of remarkable. He answers many of the thousands of emails he receives. I respect his decision, but I think there's something bigger going on here.

Cuban is the second influential blogger to openly poo-poo comments this month. Earlier, Seth Godin made similar remarks. I wonder if in part this is because the tools for moderating and mining comment data are pitiful.

This is one reason why some - myself included - don't find intra-blog conversation nearly as valuable as the inter-blog dialogue. I can search and measure the latter in ways I can't with the former. Blog comments are great and valuable to read, but still hard to sift, sort and respond to if you get a lot of them. Hopefully some smart entrepreneurs will fix this soon. When a blog like Mark's gets hundreds of comments per post, you need something to help you mine it all.

Technorati Tags: ,

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/12807/5169416

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Cuban Kills Blog Comments:

» Blog Maverick turns off comments, becomes broadcast company from bitemarks
By Daniel N. Bernstein Internet philosopher Clay Shirky, in his influential Power Laws Weblogs and Inequality, wrote: As a blogger's audience grows large, more people read her work than she can possibly read, she can't link to everyone who wants [Read More]

» Blogs Without Comments are NOT Blogs from InstaBLOKE... a bloggers natural resource
I can only wonder if Cuban also considers his cheering fans (that pay for his seats) useless banter as well? And for the record I won't link to any site that [Read More]

» Cuban Turns Off Comments from Small Business Blogging
Dallas Mavericks owner and Blog Maverick blogger Mark Cuban has decided to disable the commenting system, practically shutting down the readers ability to comment directly on the blog. He closes a post about being called names by saying, For th... [Read More]

» Downside of blogs from Confluence: Debra Adams
Are blog comments not worth the trouble? [Read More]

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I think the heat of losing the finals finally got to him. Are there way too many puns in that sentence? unintentional foul.

It's a tough call for a popular blog like his, but his sports-related (99% NBA) posts bring out the crazy sports fan in many and I can understand why he'd flip them off. Too many nuts, too many trolls. However, I wouldn't be surprised if he flipped them back on for some tech-related posts in the near future.

I wonder if there is a better way to manage the community that revolves around bloggers. There almost has to be, but don't ask me what it is.

Typepad could easily package a solution as an uber-premium service ... using some of the same technologies as Gmail. Thing is, I wonder if it's actually worth the investment to develop. Really, how many bloggers actually face similar problems??

I think that Daniel in the post above has hit the nail on the head; the market for a product like this would be very small. the criteria would be:
a - huge volumes of comments
b - an author who is actually concerned about the content of the comment
Micro market I think. (Sorry, no pun intended here either...)

It’s a pretty amazing turn considering his openess. I previously posted there a few times, and the discussions were for the most part, intelligent back and forth. Not sure what happened recently between him and fans though.

As for market for this kind of tool to mine content? I see it as VERY useful for agencies and brands to scan all the blogs out there for any relevant consumer insights/comments based on key search phrases and/or words.

I think Mark is just going thru a hard time. I'm sure he'll turn on comments when he cools off.

Bloggers with significant communities are finding it tough to manage trackbacks, comments and spam to both especially.
Whilst we wait for decent tools to emerge busy bloggers are closing down these areas of functionality, but I believe we're losing a critical piece of the conversation that shouldn't be underestimated. Dialogue is what it's all about, and - whether it's easier to track or manage or not - that dialogue isn't as direct or 'democratic' if it relies on the other half of the conversation taking place on the reader's own blog. Many people will not write their own blogs, for example.
I really hope comments don't die in the long term, and certainly don't expect them to, if only because of their enormous value.

First thing that comes to mind is the digg comments feature that eventually hides the comment when enough people give it a negative, and can be viewed only if the user chooses to. Secondly, this could prevent negative comments due to the fact the poster would know it will soon be buried and thus a waste of time and in some ways embarrassing. Automatic filters will never work to the extent that "democratic" filters will.

Chris, do people really care enough to digg comments??

Of course. You do know of Digg, don't you? The thumbs up and thumbs down feature on individual comments. If people are spending time commenting, they would surely exercise expressing their opinions on another comment by clicking a button to give it a positive or negative vote. This would assist in controlling comments, in a different way.

I don't think he should do it. It seems like he doesn't want feedback anymore.

He could have easily implemented technology to make moderating the comments very easy.

Everyone seems to have conflicting numbers on how many people read blogs and how many actively participate by posting etc. But as the number that actively participate grows can a single person with a popular blog actually be expected to keep it completely interactive?
With a corporate blog, a team can be assigned to moderate comments, and while Cuban could definitely afford 'people' to do this for him that doesn't seem to be his style.

comment is disabled on this entry. but you can comment on later entries.

he'll turn on comments when he cools off.

I really hope comments don't die in the long term, and certainly don't expect them to, if only because of their enormous value

hi
very nice idea
thanks
http://ankara_evden_nakliyat.sitemynet.com/

nice note!No one really has a confident feel on what this news could be. Some have suggested the release date may be pushed up to next nba live Tuesday, but its hard to believe EA would want to 火箭 release Live on the same day as Halo 3. On the other hand nbalive it would still accomplish beating out NBA 2K8 to the store shelves. Both currently are set to be in 火箭队 stores on Tuesday October 2nd.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

Search


Subscribe

My Lifestream

Contact Me

Recent Comments

Miscellany