Micro Persuasion: Google Gets Away With What Microsoft Couldn't

Wednesday, February 16, 2005

Google Gets Away With What Microsoft Couldn't

Google today launched a new version of its toolbar that employs a new feature called Autolink that turns non-linked content on Web sites into hotlinks back to Google properties and other sites. Gary Price writes...

For example, say your browsing a web page with numerous addresses on it. AutoLink will turn each of those addresses into direct links to the Google Maps database.

In addition to addresses, it will also add links for ISBNs, package tracking numbers, and vehicle identification numbers. This all has Greg Linden a bit spooked. I agree. How come nobody is crying foul here? Remember all the heat Microsoft took over its planned Smart Tags feature a few years ago? Gary alludes to it, but I think that there should be more discussion here. Let's face it, Google is to the Web what Microsoft is to PCs - the operating system everyone uses to search. It has nearly the same lock on consumers' share of mind (sorry Yahoo). And millions use the Google Toolbar. They shouldn't get away with what Microsoft was unable to. It's not fair and it shows that no matter what Google does, they can do no wrong in the eyes of the American public - at least for now. Could you imagine the uproar if Microsoft had tried this with the new MSN Toolbar Suite?

UPDATE: Dan Gillmor also weighs in on this thread, saying Google's move is a bad idea.

Posted at 07:40 PM in Search | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c5e1c53ef00d834222d5753ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Google Gets Away With What Microsoft Couldn't:

» Another reason why I won't install the Google Toolbar from The Newest Industry
As Steve Rubel points out, Google is stealing some of Microsoft's worst ideas. [here] I wonder how long before the wave crests, and the undertow sucks Google out to the Island of the Damned. [Read More]

» Google Gets Away With What Microsoft Couldn't from Oloop.org
'Google today launched a new version of its toolbar that employs a new feature called Autolink that turns non-linked content on Web sites into hotlinks back to Google properties and other sites. Gary Price writes...' Micro Persuasion: Google Gets Away... [Read More]

» Google Toolbar and Autolink: badness afoot from Exchange Security

Smart tags are exceptionally useful in Office, because you can easily write your own smart tag code to recognize objects unique to your business (like chemical compound names for a pharmaceutical company).... If an Internet Explorer 6 user visits ... [Read More]

» Non sono cattiva, e' che mi disegnano cosi' from Paolo's Weblog.
E' noto che una delle principali linee guida per il comportamento in Google � "don't do evil", non fare del male. [Read More]

» Micro Persuasion: Google Gets Away With What Microsoft Couldn't from VRlog
Micro Persuasion: Google Gets Away With What Microsoft Couldn't : "Google today launched a new version of its toolbar that employs a new feature called Autolink that turns non-linked content on Web sites into hotlinks back to Google properties and other s [Read More]

» Google goes where MS couldn't from mike's web log
Steve Rubel notes that Google is experimenting with a technique that Microsoft was roundly trashed for: auto-linking content in a page. (Microsoft's version was Smart Tags.) Google looks through the page creating links out of anything it can: "In addit... [Read More]

» Google "dumb tags" from rexblog
Google "dumb tags": Says Dan Gillmor (and earlier, Steve Rubel ), "Google is starting to act in ways that are reminiscent of our favorite monopolist." Read the whole thing . [Read More]

» Here we go again; Google "Smart Tags" from iRi
Google today launched a new version of its toolbar that employs a new feature called Autolink that turns non-linked content on Web sites into hotlinks back to Google properties and other sites.... In addition to addresses, it will also add links for ... [Read More]

» Google's World Domination from Dave's Ramblings
Apparently Google is taking the next step towards world domination. Hey let's face it, Google is an awesome search engine, they offer many fantastic services, but do I really want them taking over my browser completely? There was a reason I moved to ... [Read More]

» Google Autolink stinkingly reminiscent of smart tags from Things that ... make you go hmm
Sure we've been here before with Microsoft Smart Tags and though that idea sucked, at least we could remove them by putting in a special tag in the source of the document. Google, who should be able to Google the internet past better than anybody ... [Read More]

» change required from Floozy Speak!
Wow today has been a great day! Got alot done and my mind is racing with new ideas and concepts. Lately at work I've been hell bent on doing things better, and in particular finding better tools to help us... [Read More]

» Google’s New Toolbar from Michael Martelli Jr.'s Blog
Google released a new version of their Toolbar, of course still in beta, and there is quite an uproar going on about it in the blogging world. The problem, that most say, is with the AutoLink feature - which... [Read More]

» Google does the MS thing... from The Web Jungle
Google does user-centric things but rewriting webpages in order to insert commercial URLs is a bit too far off! [Read More]

» Google Toolbar 3 Beta - Second Approach to SmartTag? from Marketing Loop Blog
Google launches a new beta toolbar with a few new features, including WordTranslator and AutoLink. Follow this link to learn more about Google Toolbar. The AutoLink feature is what causing a controversy. Read more about it at Micro Persuasion, Googl... [Read More]

» Googlebar from bblog
Google's got a new toolbar version out and it's got a lot of nice features. Of course, I'm a Mac guy at home so I can't use any of them and a Firefox user at work so I can't use... [Read More]

» Google Tool Bar BETA from The 13th Colony
Why are we willing to let google do something we would never let Microsoft do? What is it about google that makes us think of it differently than Microsoft?, could it be the illusion of choice, we choice to use google. We don't chose to use Windows o... [Read More]

» Where is the "Prevent Autolink"-Tag? from Useful Sounds - Nicole Simon's english [blog|podcast]
Steve Rubel asks in "Google Gets Away With What Microsoft Couldn't"How come nobody is crying foul here? ... They shouldn't get away with what Microsoft was unable to. It's not fair and it shows that no matter what Google does, they can do no wrong in ... [Read More]

» Getting down on Google from aTypical Joe: A gay New Yorker living in the rural south.
Everyone's getting down on Google this week. First I got a "Very Important, please read!" email from three people telling me that Google has a "new feature" that let's you type someone's phone number in and get back a map... [Read More]

» Controverse autour de la barre d'outils de Google from miss-information.net
De nouvelles fonctions d'ajout d'hyperliens dans la barre d'outils offerte par Google soulève bien des questions, certains y voyant une tentative du géant de la recherche sur le Web de canaliser les clics. [Read More]

» So? from larry borsato
There's been so much fuss the past few days about the new Google Toolbar and the Autolink feature adding hyperlinks in the browser window. I use Firefox, the browser that has been downloaded 25,000,000 times so far. Boing Boing stats... [Read More]

» Google changes its model from "Don't be evil" to "Arrrrrrr...." from Betsy Devine: Funny Ha-Ha or Funny Peculiar?
Avast, ye scurvy dogs formerly known as Google! Steve Rubel , Dave Winer , and Dan Gillmor have the real story about Google's new" AutoLinks "--which turn out to be the same idea as Microsoft's idea for "Smart Tags"--and were apparently dreamed up by the [Read More]

» Are there legal implications of the Google's new AutoLink feature? from Loosely Coupled // Tim Marman's Weblog
[Read More]

» Google Attempts to Hijack Web Content from KasLog
Normally I have only praise for all things Google, but the new toolbar browser plug-in is evil. Gary Price reports that it inserts links into web pages that point to sponsored content. In other words, the links on the page you are looking at have nothi... [Read More]

» Are there legal implications of the Google's new AutoLink feature? from Loosely Coupled // Tim Marman's Weblog
[Read More]

» Google AutoLink: Doesn't Cross the Line, Yet from Freedom to Tinker
Google's new Toolbar includes a feature called AutoLink that adds hyperlinks to certain content in Web pages. For example, if it spots a street address in the page, it hyperlinks the address to Google Maps; if it spots the ISBN number for a book, it hy... [Read More]

» The Google Toolbar Excitement from The Closed Circle
The BBC just got round to commenting on the Google Toolbar 3 upset, so maybe I ought to quickly post a summation of what's happening. Search engine firm Google has released a trial tool which is concerning some net users because it directs people t... [Read More]

» Google ... beware the Dark Side! from Neuvo
A little while ago, Steve Rubel of Micro Persuasion wrote about a new feature in Google's browser toolbar that uses a feature called 'Autolink" which performs a similar function to Microsoft's SmartTags: [Read More]

» Google Toolbar's AutoLink & The Need For Opt-Out from Search Engine Watch Blog
AutoLink is new feature in the new third version of Google's popular Google Toolbar that's raised controversy since it was released last week. Why are publishers upset? Can they block the feature that adds links to their web pages? Who... [Read More]

» Google Auto-link from DocBug
Google's Auto-Link feature is generating all sorts of commentary, most of it the perennial "have they crossed the line into scary all-your-base-are-belong-to-us mode yet" type. I've not seen the interface... [Read More]

» More Google shenanigans from JackLewis.net
WizBang worries about Google's new AutoLink feature. Jeff Zeldman and Steve Rubel explain it in more detail. Chris Kaminski explains... [Read More]

» Why Google isn't what it used to be from Matt McAlister
The AutoLink debate seems more like the catalyst for venting frustration in a perception shift than a real complaint about the technology. Google was once the ena... [Read More]

» Google Reconsider Autolink from Website Rankings Tools FREE SEO Help UK
The big news, however, is that Google sounds like it might be listening, yet they are leaving their options open. Here are excerpts... The Google feature is more benign than Microsoft's for several reasons. Still, the way it is being implemented is ... [Read More]

» Google Reconsider Autolink from Website Rankings Tools FREE SEO Help UK

Walt Mossberg weighs in on Google Autolink in today's Wall Street Journal. Basically his stance is consistent with what he wrote in 2001 on Smart Tags.

[Read More]

» Everyone's getting down on Google from aTypical Joe: A gay New Yorker living in the rural south.
First I got a "Very Important, please read!" email from three people telling me that Google has a "new feature" that let's you type someone's phone number in and get back a map to their home. Horrors! This from people... [Read More]

» New Google Feature May Affect Real Estate Websites from BlogArizona.com - An Arizona Real Estate Blog
The tech world and many internet advertisers are in an uproar over a new feature called 'Autolink' which is part of Google Toolbar 3 (the newest version). [Read More]

» Are there legal implications of the Google's new AutoLink feature? from Loosely Coupled // Tim Marman's Weblog
A lot of folks are up in arms about the AutoLink in Google's new beta toolbar (which I mentioned here).... [Read More]

» Information is Power and Geeks Rule from Blog Bloke (your blogging resource)
And Whosoever Holds the Keys to the Information, Holds All of the Power. Is GoogleBot the Beast or the AntiChrist? I'm not hedging any bets. The point is this - Google is in a position to be far more abusive of your rights than Microsoft could ever ... [Read More]

» Google's dominance and proxy web accelerator from Brian's blog: internet business, search, and marketing on the web
I asked in the Platinax forums a few days ago about Google's current dominance in search. The response so far - it's unavoidable, and possible even necessary. Certainly that's true to a point - Google have gotten where they are... [Read More]